Friday 20 July 2018

Why Burberry Destroyed £30m of its Products - An Introduction to Artificial Scarcity


How companies artificially rig markets to work in their favour- and how it gets a lot darker than just burning handbags...

Burberry has recently caused quite a stir after a controversial business practice was recently revealed. News broke that the British high-end luxury fashion brand has incinerated as much as £28m of its own cosmetics and fashion products over the past year, to protect the brand and eradicate counterfeiting.

While these latest revelations have drawn attention to Burberry, this practice of destroying one's own stock is not by any means new in the fashion industry. H&M has a deal in Sweden to burn its own unwanted stock to produce energy. Slashed shoes were found disposed outside a Nike store in NYC. And Richemont, the group whose portfolio includes luxury watchmaker Cartier, has reportedly destroyed more than £400m of luxury watches over the past 2 years.

The most significant threat of these surplus products to a company like Burberry is not the aiding of counterfeiting, rather the potential effect the sale of such items on the grey market could have on the brand. The grey market, unlike the black market, is not necessarily illegal- rather it is a market which sells goods obtained unofficially. Some argue that popular retailers such as TK Maxx are examples of the grey market- obtaining genuine branded items, some of which are from unofficial channels, and selling them for less than the brand itself.

Burberry's concern is this: if their goods found their way to a shop like TK Maxx, and were sold for a fraction of their actual price, what would be the perceived value of the bags which it sells for full price? The appeal of a luxury brand is exclusivity; the grey market offers anything but this. What's more, it is highly unlikely that the original brand gets any of the grey market revenue at all.

Considering all this, Burberry's incineration of its own goods is an investment in the company's brand, protecting its goods from reaching the grey market and helping to maintain high prices. This is artificial scarcity.

Why is this scarcity artificial?

Well, the fact that the surplus goods existed shows that Burberry can produce than it is putting onto the market. Through artificially reducing supply (burning it), Burberry can keep demand, and thus prices, high.

To provide contrast, an example of genuine scarcity could be the recent CO2 shortage confronting many beverage manufacturers. The shortage of carbon dioxide has restricted the production of fizzy beverages, which, if prolonged, may force producers to raise prices.

The spread of Burberry's brash act in the news has brought practices that ensure artificial scarcity to light, but in reality, pretty much every business enforces some type of artificial scarcity. Few companies (perhaps, except Tesla) genuinely produce at their maximum capacity, whether to protect their brand as Burberry does, or to protect costs.

Disregarding the contemptible waste of material involved in some methods of creating it (think of how much leather Burberry burned), one could argue artificial scarcity is too substantial an issue. When it comes to luxury brands, for example, few people suffer from not being able to afford a £1000 handbag.

Where artificial scarcity does come into issue is in industries whose products we depend heavily upon. The pharmaceutical sector is an example; producers with monopoly power over certain drugs can in effect hold its users at ransom by restricting production and sending prices rocketing. Investigations have found this to be happening with medical products as widely used as stents, where some US firms were found to be exporting an increasing number of stents to India, but distributing fewer, despite demand increasing.

The Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries (known as OPEC) also leverage artificial scarcity to their benefit. Its members, which include Saudi Arabia, Venezuela and the UAE, are able to control global oil prices through co-ordinating their output. If it is decided that a rise in oil prices would benefit members, all members reduce their output of oil, and if an oil price cut is desired, they increase output. Such organisations are known as 'cartels'- illegal in most instances due to their lack of competition, but uncontrollable in the case of an organisation as influential as OPEC.

Artificial scarcity is always working in favour of businesses, rarely (if ever) working in favour of consumers. In the consumer world, it can cause massive waste, but little other genuine threat to consumers themselves.

However, when artificial scarcity is a tactic leveraged in potentially life-changing industries, such as pharmaceuticals and natural resources, it exposes capitalism at its most vicious- wealthy producers holding consumers depending on their product at ransom, and benefiting from their desperation.

Lone Editor

14 comments:

  1. Naviforce is a synonym for style and luxury when it comes to watches. Being a public favorite for years, Naviforce watches Pakistan are a known brand about the public Buy Naviforce watches in Pakistan at discounted Price All latest Design, buy best quality watches at the sale price Maximum Discount buy now

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have given marketing assignment help to students and companies from different parts of the world and I can say this thing with a guarantee that it was a marketing strategy of Burberry. This marketing tactic would have brought Burberry more people and business and a similar strategy was used by the other brands on your list.


    ReplyDelete
  4. HARDCORE CYCLES was started in the Greater Philadelphia area by a group of tight friends with a passion for V-Twin performance aftermarket parts.Visit our Website Thanks
    Smooth Sissy Bar Pad

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. We are a pipe manufacturing company and provide a wide range of plastic Pipes, UPVC pipes and PVC pipe fittings. we have visited your website first time and really impressed all your effort what you have done here. Keep sharing

    ReplyDelete
  7. It’s very helpful. Thanks for share with us. Please visit my website.

    Satta number
    Satta Bajar

    ReplyDelete
  8. Panther Jackets Is A Leather Jackets WareHouse Providing Jackets In USA, Canada and UK.With Free Shipping
    def jam jacket
    pornhub varsity jacket
    workaholics bear jacket

    ReplyDelete
  9. PDR Technician Earnings - Fact or Fiction? Yes, that's right - the claim made by some PDR Technicians are that an experienced PDR technician can earn as much as surgeons! The paintless dent removal industry has existed for the past 30 years in Australia and not many know about its existence! https://redhotdistributors.com/

    ReplyDelete
  10. Such an informative post. The article is really helpful. Thanks for sharing the knowledge and experience.
    David Harbour Stranger Things Blazer

    ReplyDelete
  11. I've been following you for the past three years because I think your thoughts are always valuable and illuminating. As a first-year university student, I like reading blogs because they take human mistake out of the equation. Because mistakes are inevitable, even the do my assignment nz that I use make sure to review and reread their work before submission.

    ReplyDelete
  12. It is interesting to read that brands are taking action to manage prices. Your article has inspired me to do more research on sustainable fashion and to be more mindful of the impact of my consumption habits. Some Top Dissertation Writing Services like The Academic Papers UK are raising awareness about the need for sustainable fashion practices.

    ReplyDelete
  13. "It's intriguing to learn that brands are actively taking measures to regulate prices. Your article has motivated me to conduct further research on sustainable fashion and to be more conscious of the consequences of my consumption patterns. Certain renowned dissertation writing services, like The Academic Papers UK, are actively promoting the importance of sustainable fashion practices."
    https://dissertationexpertsuk.co.uk/dissertation-writing-service/

    ReplyDelete